Incongruent coping

“Silence is compliance – A protester with a message standing on a window ledge in Whitehall.” by alisdare1 is licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0

Incongruent coping refers to responses to stress or trauma that do not align with an individual’s authentic needs, emotions, or long-term well-being. While coping strategies can help manage distress, incongruent coping is distinct in that it involves compliance, passivity, or denial; often mimicking the “freeze” response in trauma, rather than genuine engagement or resolution. frontiersin

Incongruent coping; compliance, emotional disengagement, and passive “freezing”, is a trauma-driven survival strategy. Although safer in the short-term, it limits growth and contributes to distress unless recognized and transformed into more adaptive, congruent coping and incongruent coping styles.

Defining Incongruent Coping

“Passive withdrawal, emotional detachment, and compliance; hallmarks of incongruent coping; represent the freeze trauma response, offering temporary safety at the cost of long-term well-being.” pioneerpublisher

Core Concept: Incongruent coping occurs when a person’s outward coping strategy (such as compliance, passivity, or emotional numbness) does not match their inner experience, goals, or needs. This misalignment creates internal tension, psychological discomfort, and longer-term distress. frontiersin

Clinical Link: Incongruent coping is most often associated with avoidance strategies, such as emotional suppression, freezing (compliance), or detachment; representing a psychological “shutdown” in the face of overwhelming threat, conflict, or trauma.

Comparison with Other Coping Styles

Coping Style	Associated Trauma Response	Typical Behaviours	Outcome/Effects
Incongruent Coping	Freeze/Compliance	Passivity, emotional numbness, compliance, “laying flat”	Chronic stress, internal conflict, loss of agency pioneerpublisher
Maladaptive Coping	Flight/Addiction	Avoidance, substance use, escapism	Reinforcement of avoidance, poor adjustment, risk behaviors rjep
Maladaptive Coping	Fight/Aggression	Anger, hostility, self-blame, interpersonal conflict	Unresolved trauma, externalizing symptoms psychologyinrussia
Adaptive Coping	Approach/Problem-Solving	Active problem-solving, seeking support	Growth, resilience, emotional regulation snku.krok

Trauma Response and Coping

Freeze/Compliance: Incongruent coping is closely related to the “freeze” trauma response, affected individuals may comply, submit, or numb themselves to survive emotionally overwhelming events. Rather than resolve the issue, this strategy can entrench helplessness and chronic distress. pioneerpublisher

Flight/Addiction: Maladaptive coping often takes the form of flight, escape, or addiction; seeking to avoid pain or reality through substances, compulsive behaviours, or dissociation. rjep

Fight/Aggression: Maladaptive coping can also manifest as aggression, blaming, or hostility; externally directed attempts to manage internal threat, often perpetuating cycles of conflict. psychologyinrussia

Freeze and Compliance as Survival: Particularly for those with histories of powerlessness or childhood trauma, incongruent coping through freeze/compliance may offer immediate survival, but at the long-term cost of authenticity and psychological health.

Insights and Clinical Applications

Chronic Incongruence: Over time, incongruent coping drains resilience, making genuine change harder and leaving individuals more vulnerable to anxiety, depression, and physical illness. frontiersin

Therapeutic Approach: Effective therapy aims to help clients move from incongruent/passive coping toward adaptive, authentic engagement—integrating emotional truth and actionable resilience. mdpi

Extreme Compliance: Complete submission

Extreme compliance, manifesting as caring for, protecting, or even loving one’s abuser (as seen in phenomena such as Stockholm Syndrome, cult recruitment, and pervasive blame cultures), is a powerful form of incongruent coping. This survival mechanism arises under intense, prolonged threat and psychological manipulation, causing the individual to internalize the abuser’s narrative and adopt beliefs and behaviours profoundly misaligned with their true self or best interests. pioneerpublisher

Extreme Compliance as Incongruent Coping

Under relentless stress, fear, or dependence, the “freeze” response evolves into full compliance. Individuals may come to identify with, defend, or even cherish those who harm them because the alternative flight or fight responses (escape, resistance) feel too dangerous or are impossible.

Brainwashing and Total Submission: In cults and abusive relationships, systematic use of threat, isolation, and controlled rewards erodes personal will and critical thought. The subject’s genuine needs and values are suppressed in favour of those imposed by the controlling figure or group. pioneerpublisher

Stockholm Syndrome: Victims align emotionally and psychologically with their captor, rationalizing abuse or even developing affection, to preserve a sense of safety or hope, no matter how illusory.

The Role of Threat and Learned Helplessness

Intense Conditioning: Repeated exposure to situations where resistance brings immediate pain, punishment, or further threat erases hope for escape or rescue. Compliance and identification with the aggressor become “the only safe option”. This is a form of psychological adaptation known as learned helplessness. frontiersin

Total Adoption of the System: Outward agreement becomes inward conviction. Victims internalize the abuser’s reality: “They care for me, only I understand them, I belong here,” reinforcing the incongruence between true inner needs and external behaviour.

Blame Culture and Incongruence

Societal Impact: In cultures where blame is weaponized by punishing dissent and rewarding submission, thus people are trained to take responsibility for harm done to them, or to parrot the narratives of those in control. This enforces chronic incongruence at personal and collective levels. pioneerpublisher

Psychological Costs

Erosion of Self: Authentic identity, emotional autonomy, and the capacity for healthy connection are damaged by long-term incongruent compliance.

Necessity of Recognition and Support: Recovery requires safe environments, validation, and the gradual rebuilding of agency and self-trust.

“Under extreme threat, compliance becomes the adaptive strategy, but at the cost of internalizing the aggressor’s values, erasing hope, and deeply damaging the authentic self. ”frontiersin

Extreme compliance; protecting, loving, and adopting the abuser’s world is a severe form of incongruent coping that emerges when all other panic responses promise only pain. Whether in abusive relationships, cults, or blame cultures, this pattern reflects the tragic logic of survival through self-betrayal, and the urgent need for awareness, compassion, and authentic rescue. frontiersin+1

Long-term, subtle narcissistic abuse

“Findings indicate that NPD partners typically begin relationships with intense idealization, which gradually shifts to criticism, manipulation, and emotional abuse. Participants reported emotional exhaustion, diminished self-worth, and symptoms resembling post-traumatic stress. ”journal.unesa

Long-term, subtle narcissistic abuse can gradually undermine a person’s confidence, independence, and sense of reality, often leaving them socially and economically trapped, and without realizing the extent of their victimization until the abuser openly escalates harm. This insidious process is a major driver of extreme compliance, where negative coping morphs from passive endurance into active support and enforcement of the abuser’s agenda. journal.unesa

Mechanisms of Slow-Burn Narcissistic Abuse

Gradual Undermining: Narcissists often begin relationships with charm and idealization, slowly introducing criticism, manipulation, and micro-abuse over time. The incremental nature, often akin to the “boiling the frog” analogy, ensures the victim adapts, doubts themselves, and loses the reflex to escape or resist. journal.unesa

Economic and Social Trapping: As support systems erode, victims become increasingly dependent on the abuser, both financially and emotionally. The lack of meaningful outside support; societal, familial, or institutional, almost always deepens the isolation and makes compliance a perceived necessity. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih+1

Turning Victims into Enforcers: Over time, the victim may adopt the abuser’s values, defend or excuse their behaviour, and even help enforce abuse against others. Society often misreads this change as “healing” or adjustment, not recognizing it as a product of chronic trauma and coercive conditioning. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih+1

Why Hope Fades

“The abuser imposing challenging financial and sexual behaviours… There were complex changes, including victims defending relatives with narcissism and imposing similar abuse on others.”pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih

Loss of Agency: The abuser succeeds when the victim feels there’s no alternative, no hope, and no help. Asking for help is often abandoned as a “lost cause”; compliance is reframed as survival.

Brainwashing and Identification: The transformation can reach a point where the victim, in their re-created self-image, polices themselves and others, perpetuating the abuser’s values. This mirrors cult recruitment tactics and severe cases of Stockholm Syndrome, where the line between victim and supporter vanishes. journal.unesa+1

Societal Blindness and Blame

Society and bystanders often fail to recognize these signs, misreading enforced compliance as wellness or recovery. Support systems may fail the victim, leaving them further isolated and entrenched in the abuser’s world.

Recovering from this form of abuse requires deep support, validation, and systemic awareness; breaking the cycle of blame and returning genuine agency to those affected. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih

Slow, subtle narcissistic abuse expertly erodes confidence and independence, creating conditions for extreme compliance and even active enforcement of the abuser’s will. Without robust social and institutional support, victims are isolated and transformed; frequently misread as “healed,” when in truth, they are deeper in the cycle of incongruent coping and loss of self. journal.unesa

References

Frontiers in Psychology, 2019. The Coping Circumplex Model: An Integrative Model of the Structure of Coping With Stress. frontiersin

Pioneer Publisher, 2024. Positive Psychology Integration Intervention Strategies for the Psychological Phenomenon of “Laying Flat”. pioneerpublisher

Wiley, 2024. Coping Flexibility: Match Between Coping Strategy and Perceived Stressor Controllability Predicts Depressed Mood. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih

RJEP, 2024. Coping Strategies of Adolescents With Varying Degrees of Drug Addiction. rjep

Pioneer Publisher, 2024. Positive Psychology Integration Intervention Strategies for the Psychological Phenomenon of “Laying Flat”. pioneerpublisher

Frontiers in Psychology, 2019. The Coping Circumplex Model: An Integrative Model of the Structure of Coping With Stress. frontiersin

The Psychological Effects of Relationships with Individuals Having Narcissistic Personality Disorder on Victims. Journal of Unesa, 2025. journal.unesa

Pathological narcissism: An analysis of interpersonal dysfunction within intimate relationships. PMC, 2021. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih

https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2019.00694/pdf

https://www.pioneerpublisher.com/SPS/article/view/1140

https://rjep.ru/jour/index.php/rjep/article/view/720

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11903985/

http://psychologyinrussia.com/volumes/pdf/2021_3/Psychology_3_2021_180-199_Bityutskaya.pdf

https://snku.krok.edu.ua/index.php/vcheni-zapiski-universitetu-krok/article/view/1112

https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fnbeh.2023.1188878/full

https://www.mdpi.com/2077-0383/10/14/3122/pdf

https://ojs.svako.lt/PSTP/article/view/354

https://mtcpe.rsmu.press/archive/2023/3/4/abstract?lang=en

https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/pon.5238